• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • What
    • Recruiting & Exec Search
    • Outplacement
    • Diversity Leadership
  • Why
    • Benefits / Value
    • Experience
    • Results
  • Blog
    • Advice & Thought Starters
    • Other Resources
  • About
    • History
    • Our Team
  • Contact

Thunderclap | Advertising and Marketing Recruiter

When you bring business development strategies to recruiting, it's the perfect storm for success.

Advice & Thought Starters

By SteveCongdon

New CMOs without heavy category experience

A couple of newsworthy Chief Marketing Officer changes you should know more about… And keep in mind as you read about these changes, there might be opportunity at the brands these marketing leaders are now leaving.

Subway gets new CMO from Michael’s. The brand is making other leadership changes, too. Carrie Walsh joins this sandwich brand from Michael’s. And before that, Carrie’s worked at Susan G. Komen and YUM brands.

Impossible Foods hires new marketing chief from Google. Yes. That plant-based meat brand. And this new leader has a fascinating and unexpected background. Jessie Becker’s marketing past includes successful stints at Google and Netflix. As the press release reads, the Impossible Burger is sold in nearly tens of thousands of restaurants across the US and in every type of cuisine.

Tropical Smoothie Cafe brings on new Chief Marketing Officer from Floor Coverings International. Mark Montini will now lead Tropical Smoothie Cafe’s marketing efforts. The brand has over 800 locations, most of which are franchises. The company is also hiring a new digital and chief information leader. And as you’ll read, bring your data and franchise expertise to this potential pitch opportunity.

Puegot North America finds a CMO to accelerate US re-entry. Another interesting move. Lisa Mark will join the auto brand from Voya Financial. Lisa has experience on other big brands, too: Disney, Mizuno and Fox Sports.

Might be just me. But all four of these brands are bringing in marketing leaders from outside their respective categories. Hmmm. Does this suggest these brands might be more open to non-category agency pitches? Or maybe this just means your agency can help these new execs get up to speed in their respective categories. Or maybe it means…

This post was published October 18, 2019.

Filed Under: Agency Growth, Pitch Predictions, Uncategorized

By SteveCongdon

Intel, Sierra Nevada and Sirius get new CMOs

Here’s some intel on three brands bringing on new marketing leadership.

Intel hires CMO from Cisco. Karen Walker joins this giant tech company from having spent ten years with another tech brand, Cisco. The Ad Age article offers up some intel on recent Intel organization and strategy changes that ultimately made the company shut down it’s in-house agency.

Sierra Nevada hires new first VP Marketing from Equator Coffees & Teas. Noelle Haley also brings more than six years of beer marketing experience to her new post, as she was CMO of Lagunitas (where she was promoted to that role). Looking for more more CMO change in beer? Read the article above. A variety of sized brewers are mentioned.

Sirius/XM/Pandora brings on new CMO from Ameritrade. Denise Karkos is leaving Ameritrade and joining this satellite radio giant. Seems like a great move for both the leader and the brand, as Denise is known for combining keen data analytics with tech platforms.

This post was published October 9, 2019.

Filed Under: Agency Growth, Pitch Predictions, Uncategorized

By SteveCongdon

How your agency can find new ways to generate revenue

Hello there, agency CEO, president and/or agency new business development professional.

Who isn’t looking for new ways to generate revenue? You don’t need another guru preaching about all the change happening in our space. But you might need an innovative thought or two on how your agency can win given the new realities of this ever-shifting industry landscape (insert appropriate guru talk around all the changes.)

As you think about  news ways of doing business and making money, here’s one useful tip: look beyond our profession. By all means, ya gotta do what many call the three “Cs” – explore and analyze your company, your category and your customer.

But to me, there’s an opportunity to go a bit further. I think the best new thinking comes from some liberal borrowing from relevant and sometimes unusual sources. Steal a few ideas from other industries.

The job is made even harder should you be an agency leader at a large agency.

Which is why you should check out this article from the Harvard Business Review blog. Entitled, “Can Bigger be Faster,” it offers up a big picture thought on why bigger organizations can, in fact, be faster. The answer seen in the post: due to their networks. And then, they use the US Army, one of the largest organizations in the world, as an example. The article identifies four strategies that are an integral part of the Army’s own change due to…wait for it…THEIR ever-shifting landscape. Sound familiar?

The post is terrific reading, written by some smart dudes. And don’t be thinking, by the way, the thoughts are relevant for big agencies only. If you’re leading a ten-person shop, you should still check out the article.

It immediately made me think about how thinking about you can rethink your agency’s networks, establish a shared purpose; create a shared consciousness; and encourage dissent. (The article’s four strategies to company transformation).

However, the problem with articles like these is that they are too broad. While I applaud big picture, head-nod thoughts like, “build relationships” and “encourage dissent,” I would take this 30,000 foot thinking and bring it down to good ol’ main street. So read the article through an agency lens. Maybe you”ll see what I did:

Technology must be a part of any new solution

Whether you use technology to encourage communication between teams, warehouse category knowledge, or optimize work flow / project management, it can be a useful tool. It can also be marketable and might provide some differentiation in, say…a new business pitch. Or in crafting a new client/agency relationship paradigm.

A dose of “change management” thinking will also be needed

I barely know what “change management” means. Here’s a high level view. Or check out wikipedia. I think it means what you think it means. What’s interesting, to me, is that whatever new operating model or change you are considering, it will be important to consider HOW the change is implemented and that you take into consideration all parties. Staff, clients, suppliers, agency owners, etc.

Test and tweak the innovation first with clients

Avoid the “no proof” objection – a sure-fire killer in new business pitches – and consider trying out and then optimizing your innovation with clients. Not your biggest ones, of course. But someone that can offer you the right balance of risk / reward. Some positive results for a client or two – a case study for your news – can do wonders.

One could even argue that you could take a crawl – walk – run approach to anything new. You do, after all, have mortgages at stake. No matter how big your agency is. Crawl: small clients. Walk: a new business pitch. Run: more external visibility, more clients, etc.

Anywho, hope this gives you an idea or two that will help your business. Check out the article, do your other “C” analysis, and then get to innovatin’. Thanks for your time today.

photo credit: The U.S. Army Multi-national training via photopin (license)

Filed Under: Agency Growth, Uncategorized

By SteveCongdon

How your agency can help CMOs create bigger impact and grow agency revenue

Traditional agencies are having a hard time. They’re trying to survive in a world where brands are rethinking the way they handle marketing. For starters: more in-housing; more projects/less AOR relationships; goodbye, CMO/hello, Chief Growth Officers.

Agency growth is stagnant. Heck, some great agencies are even closing their doors.

I suggest to you, gentle agency CEO, president, new business leader or discipline leader, that one way to help keep your client around and grow revenues is to help make sure the client/agency team is having an impact. The kind of thing that helps you solve the thing that keeps you and your client awake at night.

Here are a quick few hundred words on helping your CMO partner create bigger impact.

1. Re-purpose and redefine the client / agency relationship
I’m not quite sure if that consultant-speak delivers the thought. Might be better to illustrate this with as few sample questions:

  • How are you helping your client understand the brand’s customers? How do you help them wear the consumer hat? How can you bring them to life inside the company? Is there a digital solution?
  • How does your consumer understanding effect the make-up of things like their sales channels, regional focus or product R&D?
  • How might your client brand definition work effect a client’s HR policy? How about all the other stakeholders before it gets to consumers?
  • When and how is your agency involved in new client initiatives? Who’s in the room on the client side?
  • What services might you competently supply that would get other people in that room?

All agencies deliver business or brand results. Fewer agencies deliver thinking, ideas and services that move beyond marketing communication. Moving beyond just making ads is a great revenue growth strategy.

2. Merchandise and market the results of the client / agency partnership
Said in another way, this is helping your client sell-in and sell-through your team’s work throughout his or her organization. That’s a fairly broad idea, but I think it’s clear. The sometimes political, internal stakeholder work that all clients and prospective clients must do to justify marketing’s existence. Not to mention their own jobs. Here are some thought-starters:

  • Internal stakeholder-only digital newsletter that highlights the department’s initiatives / celebrates the brand
  • A paragraph or two (written for an internal audience) on the basics of work (what/why/when/how)
  • Demonstrating marketing and branding thought leadership via industry/target best practice sharing
  • A client/agency only digital destination capturing the team’s understanding of the target
  • Making sure the “why we advertise” presentation is ready to go (which alone will help course-correct)
  • Sharing positive trade press or consumer reaction to the work

Anywho, I hope this gets you to expand your thinking around the relationship agencies typically enjoy with their clients. Having had the privilege of working on two long standing client/agency partnerships, I can tell  you it’s the above kind of thinking that leads to happier, more productive and valuable relationships.

Thanks. And happy thinking!

photo credit: Theo Crazzolara Soya via photopin (license)

Filed Under: Agency Growth, CMO Thinking, Uncategorized

By SteveCongdon

New marketing leaders at VW, Activision and Ancestry.com

Looking for an agency pitch or two? Here’s quick intel on four brands that are changing their marketing leadership.

VW gets new US CMO from Kia. Saad Chehab joins this position in the middle of a brand repositioning. Saad has extensive experience in the autumn industry, having worked at Kia and Chrysler.

Activision Blizzard hires marketing leader from CAA. David Messinger joins the makers of Call of Duty with over 15 years of tenure at Creative Artists Agency. David has held various board positions in the entertainment industry and seems to be a great fit for his new role. Activision Blizzard is based out of Santa Monica, CA.

Changes taking place at Walmart. The Chief Marketing Officer leaves while a new leader is hired (but not a CMO). And the brand will continue to look for marketing leaders as they restructure the department.

Ancestry.com brings on new Chief Revenue Officer from Farmer’s Insurance. Mike Linton spent 8 years in marketing leadership at Farmer’s before leaving for Ancestry.com. With a title change: from CMO too CRO.

This post was published on 9/26/19.

Filed Under: Agency Growth, Pitch Predictions, Uncategorized

By SteveCongdon

Hack the fastest growing agencies for hockey stick revenue growth

Agency presidents, CEOs, agency discipline leaders and new business professionals are all interested in one thing: finding smart ways for agencies to grow. And because they want to make their bonus, ideally the growth is hockey stick shaped.

Last week, yours truly had an idea that it’d be fantastic to identify the fastest growing agencies and then suggest a few secrets to their success. And then wouldn’t you know it, Adweek introduces their first annual ranking of the Fastest Growing Agencies. Love it!

So check it out. The article features a nice little chart you can play with via Tableau. It’s pretty cool.

Not doubt as you spend some time on the list, you’ll find some inspiration. Yours truly quickly found five agency growth strategies. And here they are, along with agencies on the list that seem to illustrate the strategy.

Specialization

Specialization is a classic agency growth strategy. Agencies that caught my eye on the list include MMGY, which focuses on the travel and hospitality space. MMGY specializes in a specific category. But there are other ways agencies can specialize. They include an understanding of a specific target or brand marketplace condition.

But those are just two examples. Per the article, there’s another one on the Adweek list – Traffic Builders – that focuses on one thing: provide TV stations in over 95 U.S. markets with digital marketing products and services that these TV stations then sell locally. Their specialization is functional.

Origins story

Every agency has a story on how and why they were created. But how many of them use that story as the reason to believe their work is going to be better than the competition? Or why the work will work for brands? Check out Advoc8. Their founders are steeped in helping political candidates win. And in the fast-paced, instant reaction media world in which we live, they’ve equated that to helping brands win through events and experiences. Here’s a great quote from the Adweek story:

We know how to help brands take positions because, if you think about it, that’s what a presidential campaign is. Your brand is your candidate,” [a principal] explains. “The fact that we organically had those skills and saw the hole in the market has given us an opportunity for exponential and quick growth.”

Different capabilities / different revenue streams

What agency growth thinking doesn’t include an embrace of technology? Check out Bluewater Media, an agency seeing 225% growth. In part due to a proprietary tech platform they’ve built to “enable influencers to keep more traffic on their sites and monetize through the sale of over 5,000 products from some of the best brands in the world.” (Source: Adweek)

Or learn a bit more about Decoded Advertising — a shop with an impressive growth rate – that created their own direct-to-consumer yoga/wellness brand which generates $50,000/month. Oooof.

Different operating model

There are a few agencies on the list that are growing through another proven growth strategy: acquisition. So, not sure calling those out is all that inspiring. Seems like they craft a reason for their roll-up and market themselves under one, new banner. Or take one that is best successful and the smaller agencies gobbled up adapt that mantra.

But check out Firewood Partners, a women-minority owned business with seven offices in four countries. They have a service model that leverages a current trend: agency services embedded in client locations. Smart.

Moxie

Just like an origins story, all agencies have an internal culture and a general way about them. But do they leverage it throughout their agency? Through their people, place, positioning and surely other marketing Ps of a professional service business. Consider OKRP, a mid-sized Chicago agency, offering “big brand creativity; start-up ingenuity.” With principles like being nimble, prolific and quick, they’re cranking out some tasty work on enviable brands. I love what one of their reps says about the agency: “we have soul. It’s the difference between saying, ‘I’ll know it when I see it’ and ‘I’ll know it when I feel it.’” (Source: Adweek).

Finding the right strategy for your agency

No doubt, these are not the only secrets to these agencies’ respective success. I suspect the agencies growing the fastest – the ones with hockey stick growth – combine a few of the proven strategies.

But this list does give agency presidents, CEOs and other growth minded agency professionals a thing or two to ponder. And as you consider your own agency’s situation, targets, competition and agency brand qualities, an idea or two will present itself. And then maybe we’ll be reading about your agency next year!

Thanks for reading.

Other articles of interest:

  • Adweek follow-up on their original story (4 CEOs talk pain and strategy)
  • How to help CMOs create bigger impact (and grow agency revenue at the same time)

photo credit: TAZphotos Sunset Hockey via photopin (license)

Filed Under: Agency Growth, Uncategorized

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Go to page 4
  • Go to page 5
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 14
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Email Newsletter & RSS Feed

Sign up to receive email updates and hear what's going on with us. Includes pitch predictions and agency pitches, wins & losses.

What Others Say

  • "Thunderclap was a great partner in our search for a business development leader. They were thoughtful and transparent throughout the search and took time to understand our organization at a very deep and authentic level. Never once did it feel like a rehash of candidates who tick boxes on paper. Each candidate they presented was thoroughly vetted to our needs and our organization which made the entire process a pleasure. I look forward to working with Thunderclap on future hires."
    Director of Talent, New Business Leader search, mid-sized agency
  • “My search was for a new business leader at a mid-sized regional agency. While candidates are open to relocating to that market, it’s not on everyone’s radar screen. Steve Congdon at Thunderclap gave me a terrific candidate that the agency loved. She’s now on their Executive Leadership Committee.”
    President, leading southeast US recruiting firm
  • “We gave Thunderclap a search for a Senior AE that needed agriculture experience, which is hard to find. And they delivered."
    Senior Recruiter, regional office, global agency
  • “I’ve given Thunderclap several recruiting assignments over the years across three departments: account management, planning and new business. It’s a pleasure working with them. They know our industry and our agency very well. Their candidates fit our requirements and I know they’re a cultural fit when they come from Steve's firm.”
    Managing Director, multiple searches, global network agency
  • “The agency was looking to hire a new Group Account Director that was going to be on a plane every week. Steve found just the right professional for this Top Ten Holding Company Account. I had several great options and they were well prepared.”
    Recruiter, Group Account Director search, global holding company agency
  • "After briefing Steve on what was needed, his company was able to quickly source several well qualified candidates that matched the jobs specs. Thunderclap screened them and submitted the best of the pack. One was hired and continues to be one of our top performers. Couldn't be more pleased with Thunderclap's quick response, professionalism and [I] look forward to working together again."  
    Recruiter, New Business Leader search, 300-person holding company agency

Recent Posts

  • How to recruit agency talent to smaller markets
  • The most helpful agency new business post you’ll read in six months
  • New marketing leaders at Equifax, Bed Bath & Beyond and Panera Bread
  • Brands with new CMOs: Walmart; Byrider and WeWork
  • New marketing chiefs at Del Monte, Popeye’s and NPR

Categories

  • Agency Growth
  • Agency Recruiter Strategies
  • Career
  • CMO Thinking
  • Job Search
  • LinkedIN
  • Pitch Predictions
  • Pitches / Wins / Losses
  • Resume Help
  • Staff Retention Strategies
  • Uncategorized

Footer

About

Thunderclap has been helping agencies grow through staffing, strategy and new business since 2003. More than 70 percent of our business comes from repeat and referral sources.

Newsletter

Sign up to get recruiting tips and more.

Get In Touch

  • 3007 N Lowell Ave, Chicago, IL 60641
  • (312) 493-3901
  • info@thunderclapcg.com

Follow Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023